Nikkei or Nasdaq? Start with the hours

Most comparisons compare things you cannot use

Search which of these two suits a beginner and what comes back compares constituents, ten-year returns, volatility, and which is better to hold long term.

None of that is false. But for someone who intends to trade, it answers “which one do I buy and hold”, not “when do I sit down and read the chart”.

Holding long term and trading are two different things. The first compares the instrument. The second compares whether your hours and the market's line up.

So this piece compares one thing only: which stretches of time you can actually find in a week, and which index is suited to trading in them.

First, being able to trade is not being suited to trade

The platform is open almost all day. You can click at three in the morning. That is being able to trade.

Being suited to trade is something else — the movement in that stretch is steady, the chart has a rhythm, and your judgement has something to stand on.

In a session with no volume, a single candle can mislead you. You did not lose to the market. You lost to a chart with nothing readable in it.

Suitable sessions for three indices (Malaysian time)

Index	Suitable sessions	Which means
Nikkei JPN225	morning, afternoon and evening	it meets three kinds of routine
Nasdaq NAS100 (US index)	evening only	a late night, every time
German GER40	afternoon and evening	workable if afternoons are free

Why is the Nasdaq's suitable session only in the evening? Because that is when the market behind it is open. It cannot be changed, and it has nothing to do with which platform you use.

For the actual hours, see this piece: Nikkei JPN225: which hours suit trading in Malaysian time?

Two common routines, and how each looks

If evenings are all you have

Either one is worth considering.

The evening is when the Nasdaq has its rhythm; the Nikkei has an evening session too. The difference is that the Nasdaq's falls later, so anyone with an early start has to work out whether it is worth it.

In that case the real question is not which index, it is how late you can still judge clearly.

If your free time comes in pieces during the day

The hour before you leave in the morning, say, or the hour or two after lunch.

Here the list gets shorter. The Nasdaq has not started; the German index waits until the afternoon.

For someone whose free time is in the morning, there is effectively one choice. That is also why our focus sits where it does — not because the Nikkei is easier, but because it leaves more routines with an option.

How to fit it around a full-time job: Which index suits someone with a full-time job?

Once the hours are right, what you look at is the same

Change the index, not the method.

Whichever one you trade, we look at three things: the candle, the direction, the momentum. All three agreeing is an entry; anything less is a wait.

So “which index” is a smaller question than it feels. It settles what time you sit down, not how you judge once you are there.

Common questions

Should a beginner pick the less volatile one?

Less movement does not mean easier. What we look at is whether the movement is steady, not whether it is large. Steady movement has a rhythm you can read; disorderly movement is hard to trade at any size.

Can I trade both?

You can, but not at the start. Early on, watching two indices means spending your time switching rather than judging. Learn one rhythm properly first.

So is the Nikkei easier to make money on?

No, and we have never said so. Its advantage is having more than one suitable session, so it fits more people's routines. How many people make money has nothing to do with the index and everything to do with judgement and discipline.

How much money do I need to start?

The answer is not an amount. Work out what you are willing to lose on one trade, how long you expect learning to take, and whether losing that money would affect your life. It is set out here: How much capital do you need to trade the Nikkei?

Beginners choosing an index are usually looking for an opponent they can beat. What you are actually choosing is an opponent willing to turn up when you are free.

Watch Teddy's weekly live

We do not guarantee returns. We do not trade on anyone's behalf. This is market education, not personal investment advice. Working through this properly takes at least three months of sustained effort. Markets carry the risk of loss — decide what you can afford to risk before you begin.

Nikkei or Nasdaq? Beginners should start with the hours